Thoughts on Pope Francis’ visit from Brother Coyote, OEF

Reading Pope Francis on Peace, Justice & Caring For Creation: Respect & Forgiveness for Flawed but Courageous American “Saints”

Brother Coyote, OEF

Gary Nabhan, Brother Coyote


Gary Paul Nabhan (Brother Coyote, OEF), is an agricultural ecologist, ethnobotanist and writer whose work has focused primarily on the desert Southwest. He is considered a pioneer in the local-food and heirloom seed-saving movements.


One of the more remarkable features of Pope Francis’ visit to North America was his request that we remember and reflect upon the lives of certain charismatic Americans whom few U.S. citizens would have placed into the same category of greatness: Abraham Lincoln, Martin Luther King, Jr., Dorothy Day, Thomas Merton, and the newly sainted Junipero Serra. What do these five persons have in common? Why has each of them been either vilified or ignored by certain Americans? And perhaps most importantly, what do these selections tell us about Pope Francis’ own sense of what saintliness is, particularly as it relates to peace, justice and caring for creation?

What first strikes me about all five of these individuals is that they had suffered deep personal wounds and self-doubts that flawed or haunted them for life; they were not “infallible” saints. At age nine, Abraham Lincoln was kicked by a horse left unconscious for 24 hours; From that point on, he suffered bouts of severe depression for the rest of his life, particularly when we broke off his engagement to Mary Todd, when he was estranged from his oldest son, and during the Battle of Bull Run. He suffered from malaria, small pox, and possibly from syphilis; he was addicted to little blue pills that were laced with mercury and made him unstable. Our greatest American president lived much of his adulthood come to grips with the dark night of the soul; because of that, he was not an easy man to live with or work for.

But who can say how long it would have taken for America to deal with the issues of racism, slavery and economic inequality without him? Where would America be without those short but elegant speeches urging Americans to take the higher ground of morality and civility whose words still remain etched into our hearts and minds a century and a half after they were written?

Martin Luther King, Jr—like Nelson Mandela—was a charismatic man whose life was filled with contradictions and flawed by indiscretions that deeply hurt his own family. He often argued with or dismissed the concerns of other African-American civil rights strategists who had helped shape the very same movement to which he had committed his life. His brutal and untimely death forever changed the debate about civil rights in America as much as his life’s work had done, but allowed some Americans to sugar-coat his image rather than focusing on finishing the important work he had begun. As a result, we have witnessed within the last two years the heartbreaking and terrifying consequences of having left much of the work toward true civil rights undone for the last have century: witness Ferguson, Cleveland, Los Angeles, Baltimore, New York City, Albuquerque, and Nogales. For all his human flaws, where would we be without the powerful voice and awesome moral poetry of Martin Luther King’s speeches echoing in our heads?

Young Dorothy Day was certainly not a poster child of what are now dubbed by the media as Christian family values. While still a young woman, she hung out in Greenwich Village with a rowdy crowd of anarchists and literati, rubbing shoulders with Leon Trotsky to Eugene O’Neill. She became pregnant out of wedlock and had an abortion. While still an atheist Bohemian, Day was jailed for protesting in front of the White House in 1917 while trying to secure the right to vote for women, went on a hunger strike after her arrest. But after ten tumultuous years as an angry young woman, she married, had a daughter and became a deep practitioner of the Catholic faith. Within another five years, she met former French Brother, Peter Maurin, and co-founded the Catholic Worker, numerous settlement houses and soup kitchens. Over the next five decades, she tirelessly endeavored to live the Gospel through living with the poor. Inspired by the courageousness and example of this one woman, the Catholic Worker movement had taken root in more than 200 communities in the U.S. and 28 communities abroad. But until she died, she would sneer at anyone who tried to put her on a pedestal, snapping back at them “don’t call me a saint.”

Thomas Merton, too, got off to a rough start, losing his mother at an early age, and squandering many of his days in college as a party-boy and pretentious poet wanna-be, drinking, carousing and seducing women He fathered a child out of wedlock, a daughter who apparently died in the German air raids on London during World War II. This secret wound no doubt haunted him for the rest of his life. Enamored by St. Francis of Assisi, he tried to join a Franciscan order, but was rejected by him. He eventually landed among the Trappists of Gethsemani in Kentucky, but was frequently censored by them and by the Catholic Church. To this day, as many of the surviving brothers he lived among at Gethsemani resent his years of presence among them, for his notoriety disrupted their attempts at tranquility, while his criticisms of their lack of a commitment to a “truly contemplative life” hurt them to their core.

And yet, along with Buddhist monk Thich Nhat Hanh, the Dalai Lama and Franciscan writer Richard Rohr, perhaps no one in Christian history has ever broken open the church to true Catholicism and interfaith dialogue as Merton. He seamlessly stitched together a contemplative ecology that embraced social justice and peace with words as elegant as any offered over the entire course of Christian history.

Lastly, we must deal with the controversial canonization of Fray Junipero Serra, who emigrated from the Mediterranean to the Californias rather late in life, after distinguished career as a priest and theology professor in Majorca and a missionary to the Pame Indians in the remote Sierra Gorda in Mexico. While in the mountains of Mexico, he suffered an insect bite in in his leg caused by an insect bite, which broke out into sores that caused him much pain throughout many journeys by foot. Across thousands of miles of American soil. While in Mexico, he became an Inquisitor and harsh critic of native shamanistic practices which he took to be demon-driven witchcraft. He rigorously practiced self-flagellation with a chain adorned with sharp iron barbs, and once, when he began whipping his own back during a sermon in Mexico City, a sobbing parishioner came up, took the chain away from Serra, and whipped himself until he collapsed.

And yet, despite serving as a pioneer in the tragic colonization of California Indians, Serra was widely known for defending the dignity and the land rights of Native Californians, treating them with respect and expressing humility in the face of their own inherent spiritual power and generosity. Much of the recent criticisms about Serra in the media are not based in facts about Serra himself, but are a large indictment of the imperialism and racism associated with the entire process of missionization in the Californias.[

What do we take home from Pope Francis’s focus on these five individuals during his brief but evocative visit to North America? First, as the Pope has frequently said about his own life, he has not been infallible, but has had to learn deeply from the regrettable mistakes he made earlier in his career. And so he chose to the focus on the lives of charismatic Americans who made a marked difference in the trajectory of social justice, but were sinners just as much as they were saints. (Incidentally, we can also say this about American Indian Movement leaders Russell Means, Dennis Banks, and Leonard Peltier and native prophets such as Nicholas Black Elk and Thomas Banyacya, Sr.) They all fell as many times as they ascended to greater heights.

Secondly, all of these individuals learned from the early traumas, flaws and wounds to somehow focus on a vision beyond themselves, one of that embraced the poor, the marginalized and oppressed in an unprecedented manner. While several of them were prolific in the speaking and writing, it was how they lived more than their words alone that have changed so many lives. They were viscerally in contact with people and the earth to a depth that few of us can claim to be. To say this same thing through another metaphor, the Holy Spirit seemed to work through them despite their flaws and wounds, or perhaps because of them.

I sense that the Pope was telling Americans something we all need to hear at this critical moment in time, when the hardest work of dealing with climate change, the unprecedented number of political refugees, immigration, structural racism and grinding poverty still lie before us. We ourselves will not achieve these lofty goals by having our heads in the clouds. We must descend to the lowest levels of the earth and to the lowest stratas of our society where the most marginalized among still suffer on a daily basis, if we are to get anywhere. We must de-romanticize our heroes, de-colonize our tendencies to be merely “do-gooders,” and de-ideologize our social and environmental justice movements if we are to live and work in the Franciscan spirit of both St. Francis and Pope Francis.

Gary Paul Nabhan is an internationally-celebrated nature writer, food and farming activist, and proponent of conserving the links between biodiversity and cultural diversity. You can find out more about his work at The above blog post was reproduced with Brother Coyote’s permission. You can read more of Gary’s blog on his website.

Published in: on October 15, 2015 at 1:03 pm  Leave a Comment  

The URI to TrackBack this entry is:

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: